Some have judged that it is wrong to be “judgmental.”  Like the man who argued with me that it is “wrong to argue the Bible,” non-judgmental folks are quite judgmental when they judge us for judging!

Certain types of judgment are forbidden.  (1) Hypocritical judgment is condemned (Matthew 7:1-5).  (2) Surface judgment, judgment according to appearances and not according to objective fact, is forbidden (John 7:24).  (3) Judging a matter before one bears it is shameful and foolish (Proverbs 18:13).

Some judgment is commanded—“Judge righteous judgment” (John 7:24); “Judge in yourselves” (1 Corinthians 11:13); “Choose you this day whom ye will serve” (Joshua. 24:15).  Immediately after forbidding selfish judgment Jesus said “Give not that which is holy unto the dogs, neither cast ye your pearls before swine” (Matthew 7:6).  How can one determine if one is a hog or a dog without making a judgment?  How can one “Beware of false prophets,” without judging that one is a false prophet (Matthew 7:15)?

God has made us creatures of judgment.  We employ judgment in every aspect of life: “Is this food good for me?”  “Should I buy this?  Can we afford it?” “Do I trust her to babysit the children?”  “She married the wrong man.”  All of life is based on making judgments.  It is the way God made us!

If religious faith with its moral and spiritual values is without judgment; it is the only area wherein judgment is not exercised.  If one’s faith is beyond judgment, there can be no “right’ or “wrong” religion.  You believe in a multiplicity of Gods?  “No problem, for we are not judgmental about such issues!”  You don’t believe in God?  “Fine!”  You accept Jesus as a great moralist but not as “God manifest in the flesh”?  Hey; great we believe he is the Son of God, but who are we to judge you?”

If it is wrong to be “judgmental,” is it right to judge that your unbelieving neighbor is lost and that we must try to reach him?  If it is a sin to be “judgmental” about the church of which one is a member, why is it not a sin to be “judgmental’ about the gods in which a pagan believes?  If we should not be “judgmental” about one’s adulterous marriage; should we likewise be “non-judgmental” about a native’s polygamy?  What is your “judgment” about such questions?

Let none say that we are setting ourselves up as “judges.”  (Must one not set himself up as a judge to make such a charge against us?)  God is our Judge (James 4:12).  However, in accordance with the teaching of the word of God, we must make judgments about the course of our life before him—“Prove all things; hold fast that which is good” (1 Thessalonians 5:21).  One is not a judge when he determines that some are teachers of error, for one must “try” or test the teachers whether they be of God (1 John 4:1, 6).  Again, we are commanded to make such judgments based on the word of God.  In Revelation 2:2, the Lord commended the church for being “judgmental” of those who lied and said they were apostles.  Likewise, we are not being sinfully “judgmental,” when, after a study of the Bible, we determine that the Pope is not the apostle he claims to be (2 Corinthians 11:13-15).

The questions we have raised deserve an answer.  Will someone answer them without being ‘judgmental” of us?