“Should Not” versus “Shall Not” —John
by Douglas Hoff
One translation is as good as
another, right? Well, not always. Granted, each translation is the product of
human activity. As such, not one will be
absolutely perfect. That does not mean a
person must doubt whether he actually has God’s word in his hands. If the Bible student is using an accurate
version, then he can know and obey God’s will. The problem is that some translations take
undue liberties with the scriptures. A
good example of this is found in John
Almost from its introduction the
NIV has been known as having a Calvinistic slant on many passages. In this version the beloved John
Is the difference between should
not and shall not all that important? Yes!
Even the number of nouns (singular or plural) and tenses of verbs are
important. Jesus affirmed the truth of the resurrection based on the present
tense of the verb “am.” The scriptures records “I am the God the God of Abraham”
long after the patriarch was buried (Matthew
How can we determine the proper wording for John 3:16? Is should or shall correct? First, we ought to understand the distinction between these words in the English language. Should indicates a duty or necessity. Shall conveys a thing will definitely happen. There is a difference between saying “I should do this” and “I shall do this.” In the first case I am indicating I have an obligation. However, I may not follow through and perform it. In the second case, I am stating I will perform the task.
Now, we need to understand what the
original text means. The Greek word may
used in this verse indicates qualified negation. To show absolute denial a different word, ook, would be used. This is the absolute negative. John
So, what does all this mean? The NIV incorrectly used shall instead of should. If a person believes Jesus is the Son of God, truly believes (in the Biblical sense of obeying), then that person should not perish. However, with
free will, he may perish. He will perish if he becomes unfaithful and dies in that condition. If one used only the NIV he might believe in “once saved, always saved.” That is what “shall not perish” means.